How we research and assess reviews

In short: Software and bank comparisons on this site consider six research criteria, using published pricing and documentation. First-hand testing is included only where the article describes what was tested and provides supporting evidence. The verdict is decided before any commercial question is asked. Not every provider is covered, and the page says which ones are.

A comparison is only worth reading if you know what it is measuring. This page sets out the criteria, what is tested against what is read from a pricing page, and what gets a product excluded.

The six criteria

  • Real cost over twelve months: the price after the introductory discount ends, including any add-ons a sole trader actually needs (VAT filing, bank feeds, receipt capture). A “from £16” headline that cannot file VAT is compared at the price of the tier that can.
  • Fit for a UK sole trader: Self Assessment support, Making Tax Digital for Income Tax readiness and HMRC recognition, UK bank feeds, CIS where relevant. Features aimed at limited companies or US users count for nothing here.
  • Day-to-day usability: invoicing, expense capture, bank reconciliation and the mobile app, judged on hands-on use where I have it and on the provider’s own documentation where I do not. The page says which.
  • Honesty of the pricing page: whether the advertised price is the price you pay, how clearly limits are stated, and how much notice is given of increases.
  • Support and lock-in: how you get help, and how easily you can export your data and leave.
  • Track record: price-rise history, outages, and how the provider has treated existing customers when it changed terms.

What is tested and what is read

Prices are always read live from the provider’s own pricing page on the date shown at the foot of the article, never from a search result or a third-party summary. Feature claims are checked against the provider’s documentation. Usability judgements come from hands-on use where the page says so; where it does not, they rest on documentation and are labelled that way. I do not fabricate testing.

What disqualifies a product

A product may be unsuitable for the reader when it lacks a required feature, transparent pricing or an appropriate way to export data. Requirements depend on the article: a bank account does not need to file a tax return. Insurance, mortgages, pensions and investments are covered as general information, not personalised recommendations.

How the verdict is reached

Verdicts explain the relevant criteria, costs, limitations and alternatives. We do not claim a numerical ranking unless the article publishes the scores and calculation. A document-based comparison is not presented as a hands-on performance test. The commercial question, meaning whether a link to that product can earn a commission, is asked only after the verdict is written, and the answer cannot change it. Several leading picks on this site pay nothing.

Comparisons carry, or are being updated to carry, a section on where the winning product is weaker and what to use instead, because no tool wins for everyone.

What is not covered

Not every provider is reviewed. Coverage starts with the tools UK sole traders most commonly ask about and expands as time allows. A product not appearing in a comparison means it has not been assessed, not that it failed.

When reviews are re-checked

A source-check date records when the specific price or claim was verified. An article update date can also reflect an editorial change and does not, by itself, mean every figure was re-checked. Readers should confirm live terms with the provider before applying or buying. Where a provider has announced a future price, both the current and the future figure are shown with the date it changes.

Methodology updated 7 November 2026.