FreeAgent vs QuickBooks for sole traders: the £0 route

FreeAgent’s sole trader plan is £19 a month plus VAT, or £0 if you hold a NatWest, Royal Bank of Scotland or Ulster Bank business current account, or a Mettle account you use at least once a month. QuickBooks Sole Trader Plus is £10 a month plus VAT after a 90% discount for six months. Both are on HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax list. Checked 11 September 2026.

The FreeAgent vs QuickBooks decision for a sole trader is really a banking decision. One costs nothing if your business account is with the right bank. The other costs £1 a month for six months, then ten times that. Here are both prices together, with the conditions that decide which number you pay.

Ad

What each one actually costs

FreeAgent’s sole trader price is £19 a month, excluding 20% VAT. New customers get 50% off for six months, so £9.50, which FreeAgent’s own savings box puts at £57 saved. Annual billing is £190, or £95 for the first year, and there’s a 30-day free trial. Sole traders are rarely VAT registered, so the figure leaving your account after the discount is £22.80.

QuickBooks Sole Trader Plus is £10 a month plus VAT, £12 all in. The banner offer running on 11 September 2026 is 90% off for six months, taking it to £1. Annual billing is £108. The next plan up, Simple Start, is £16 plus VAT.

Read the offer terms before you click. The discount runs from the date of enrolment and is followed by “the then-current monthly price”. Then this: “You must select the Buy Now option and you will not be eligible for a 30-day free trial.” Deal or trial, not both, and new customers only.

The free-with-bank condition, word for word

FreeAgent’s pricing page carries a second tile below the paid one, marked “Introductory price £0.00”. The condition reads: “If you have a business current account with NatWest, Royal Bank of Scotland, Ulster Bank, for as long as you retain the account – or have a Mettle bank account and make at least one transaction a month.”

Two different tests are buried in there. For the three high street brands the test is holding the account. For Mettle the test is activity, and Mettle spells out what happens when it stops: “To get FreeAgent included, you must make at least one transaction a month from your Mettle account. If you don’t make one transaction a month, or if your Mettle account is closed and you continue to use FreeAgent then the FreeAgent fees will apply.”

There’s a third condition, printed only on the accountants tab of the same page: “Provided they make Mettle their primary business account in FreeAgent.” That’s a setting inside FreeAgent, not a statement about where your money lives. Bank where you like day to day, as long as Mettle is the account FreeAgent treats as primary.

Mettle costs nothing to open, is provided by National Westminster Bank plc trading as Mettle, and eligible deposits are FSCS protected up to £120,000. Our Mettle account review covers the limits; how FreeAgent’s free licence works goes deeper.

FreeAgent vs QuickBooks on the things HMRC checks

HMRC’s software finder had 92 products listed when I checked it on 11 September. FreeAgent appears twice: “FreeAgent”, Price shown as Paid version, and “FreeAgent for free with Mettle, NatWest & RBS”, Price shown as Free version. QuickBooks (Intuit) appears once, Paid version. All three cover quarterly updates and the tax return, sole trader and UK property.

Two differences sit in the detail pages. FreeAgent marks “Partner income from a partnership” Ready now; QuickBooks marks it Not included. QuickBooks marks “HMRC Assist (Submission Feedback)” Ready now; FreeAgent marks it Not included. Neither supports foreign property.

They describe different jobs on the return itself. FreeAgent says it lets you “File your tax return directly to HMRC (if you’re a sole trader, director of a limited company or unincorporated landlord)”, covering the Main Return, Self Employment, Employment, Tax Adjustments and UK Property forms. QuickBooks lists it as “Prepare for Self-Assessment”. Not the same promise.

Timing, from GOV.UK: qualifying income over £50,000 in 2024 to 2025 meant starting 6 April 2026, over £30,000 in 2025 to 2026 means 6 April 2027, over £20,000 in 2026 to 2027 means 6 April 2028. See MTD for Income Tax for sole traders and the full list of HMRC recognised MTD software.

True yearly cost in four situations

Ex-VAT unless stated, monthly billing, from both pricing pages on 11 September 2026.

SituationYear 1 (ex VAT)Year 2 (ex VAT)Two years inc VATThe condition attached
FreeAgent, you bank with NatWest, RBS or Ulster Bank£0£0£0For as long as you retain the account
FreeAgent, you open Mettle alongside your main bank£0£0£0Mettle set as primary in FreeAgent, one transaction a month
FreeAgent, none of those banks, paid monthly£171
(£9.50 × 6) + (£19 × 6)
£228
£19 × 12
£478.8050% off runs six months only
QuickBooks Sole Trader Plus, 90% intro then list£66
(£1 × 6) + (£10 × 6)
£120
£10 × 12
£223.20New customers, Buy Now, no 30-day trial
freeagent.com/pricing and quickbooks.intuit.com/uk/pricing, checked 11 September 2026. Both quote prices excluding 20% VAT.

Annual billing changes the third row: FreeAgent at £95 then £190 is £285 ex VAT, £342 with VAT, saving £114 against monthly. QuickBooks annual at £108 loses you the 90% offer.

Bar chart of FreeAgent vs QuickBooks two-year cost for a UK sole trader, excluding VAT: FreeAgent free with Mettle or NatWest £0, QuickBooks Sole Trader Plus £186, FreeAgent annual billing £285, FreeAgent monthly billing £399. Checked September 2026.

Two years, one freelancer, three routes

Take Priya. Freelance copywriter, Leeds, about £3,400 a month through the business, six invoices out each month, twelve receipts and bills to record, not VAT registered. She isn’t with NatWest, RBS or Ulster Bank, so the free tile doesn’t apply.

Route one, pay FreeAgent. Six months at £9.50 is £57, six at £19 is £114, so year one is £171. Year two is £228. Two years: £399 ex VAT, £478.80 with VAT. Her twelve receipts matter, because Smart Capture handles ten a month and unlimited use is a £5 add-on. Two years of that adds £120, so £519 ex VAT.

Route two, pay QuickBooks. Six months at £1 is £6, six at £10 is £60, so year one is £66. Year two is £120. Two years: £186 ex VAT, £223.20 with VAT. The plan page lists receipt capture with no monthly cap, and mileage tracking is included.

Route three, open Mettle and take FreeAgent free. Mettle costs nothing. She keeps her existing account for client payments, sets Mettle as the primary business account inside FreeAgent, and pushes one payment through it each month. Two years: £0. The ten-a-month cap still applies, so either £120 for the add-on or she keys two by hand.

So when does opening Mettle beat paying? Against FreeAgent’s own plan, immediately: £9.50 saved in month one, £399 over two years. Against QuickBooks it’s slower. Her first six months cost £6 in total, so in that window the Mettle route is worth a pound a month and isn’t worth the admin. From month seven the gap opens at £10 a month: £66 gone by the end of year one, £186 by the end of year two.

Now the catch that ruins this for people. If the monthly Mettle transaction stops, the FreeAgent fees apply, and those are £19 plus VAT, nearly double QuickBooks’ list price. The free route is only free while you remember. Set a £1 standing order out of Mettle on the 1st. That’s £0 instead of £228 a year.

Where each one is weaker

QuickBooks Sole Trader Plus does not carry “Manage and submit VAT to HMRC”. That starts at Simple Start, £16 plus VAT. If you’re near the £90,000 VAT registration threshold, treat QuickBooks’ real price as £16, because you’ll move up within the year. FreeAgent’s £19 plan files MTD VAT returns at no extra cost. Recurring invoices are the other hole: they start at Essentials, £38 plus VAT, while FreeAgent includes them.

FreeAgent’s weakness is the dependency. It’s owned by NatWest Group, which is why the free offer exists, and a decision you have no part in could change it. The Smart Capture cap is the second irritation: ten items a month is thin if you buy stock or travel.

For the third option here, FreeAgent against Xero for sole traders covers Xero’s invoice cap, and our QuickBooks review for the self-employed goes through the app. Setting the system up once is what the Digital Bookkeeping System course covers.

Open FreeAgent or QuickBooks

These buttons are affiliate links, if you open an account after clicking one we may be paid a fee by the provider. It costs you nothing extra and it hasn’t changed the verdict above. FreeAgent pays this site nothing, and it’s still the pick that leads. Pricing links in the body go direct to each provider’s own page. Full disclosure.
LEAD PICK

FreeAgent

£0 if you bank with NatWest, RBS or Ulster Bank, or hold Mettle and move money through it monthly. Otherwise £19 plus VAT after six months, and Smart Capture stops at ten items.

Visit FreeAgent
CHEAPEST PAID PLAN

QuickBooks Sole Trader Plus

£10 plus VAT once the 90% intro ends, £186 ex VAT over two years. No VAT submission and no recurring invoices, and it prepares your Self Assessment rather than filing the return.

Visit QuickBooks
THE FREE ROUTE

Mettle

Free account that gets you FreeAgent at £0. The catch: set it as your primary business account inside FreeAgent and transact monthly, or the FreeAgent fees start.

Visit Mettle

Questions worth answering

Is FreeAgent free with a Mettle account?

Yes, on two conditions. Mettle must be set as your primary business account inside FreeAgent, and you must make at least one transaction a month from it. Mettle’s terms say that if you stop, or close the account and keep using FreeAgent, the fees apply.

What does QuickBooks cost after the 90% off?

Sole Trader Plus returns to £10 a month plus VAT, £12 all in, from month seven. The terms say the discount runs from the date of enrolment “followed by the then-current monthly price”, so the figure moves if Intuit raises list prices.

Do I need to pay for MTD for Income Tax software?

No. HMRC’s finder lets you filter for a free version, and FreeAgent’s bank-linked licence is listed there as its own product, Price shown as Free version. GOV.UK’s wording: “free products are available for those with simple tax affairs but there may be limits on how the product can be used”.

If you’re deciding this week

  • Check who your business account is with first. NatWest, Royal Bank of Scotland or Ulster Bank means FreeAgent is £0.
  • If you’re not with those three, price two years rather than one: £186 for QuickBooks, £399 for FreeAgent monthly, £0 for the Mettle route.
  • Count your receipts and bills for one month. Over ten and FreeAgent’s £5 add-on goes into the sum on either route.
  • On the Mettle route, set a small standing order out of Mettle on the 1st so the free condition never lapses.
  • Run the numbers through the free UK tax calculator first, because a £228 software bill is a deductible cost against a tax bill you should already know.

This verdict rests on each provider’s published pricing and terms and on HMRC’s software list, not on months of use.

PARTNER · FREE PLAN

Need a business account? Tide is free to open

Free plan, FSCS protection up to £120,000 through ClearBank, approved in the app in minutes. Best for light use: the free plan covers five bank transfers a month, and above that the paid plans start at £12.49. Our Tide review has the full fee table.

Open a Tide account

Partner link: Tide pays us a fee if you open an account through it. It costs you nothing and did not change what we wrote above. Tide is not a bank; accounts are provided by ClearBank Ltd.

Ad

Sources

Figures checked against freeagent.com/pricing, quickbooks.intuit.com/uk/pricing, mettle.co.uk and HMRC’s MTD for Income Tax software finder on 11 September 2026. This is general information, not financial or tax advice.

Course · Edition 2026/27 · Online access

MTD quarters coming and the books are a shoebox?

Digital Bookkeeping System (MTD-ready) 2026/27. Seven modules and a seven-sheet toolkit, built around a category-to-tax-box mapping table that makes your quarterly updates fill themselves.

  • A software decision sheet costed over three years, split by turnover, VAT status and phone-or-desktop
  • The chart of categories mapped to the Self Assessment and MTD boxes, and the three categories never to auto-categorise
  • Weekly and month-end cards, an MTD quarter-close checklist, and an export-and-archive index so their cloud is never your only copy

Software is priced monthly, excluding VAT, and you will hold the subscription for years. Pick on the wrong number and the difference over three years is more than every course on this site combined.

Get it for £31£31 · free updated edition at every Budget

Buying more than one? All ten 2026/27 courses for £107, against £293 bought separately.

About The Paid Hour Team

This guide was researched and written by The Paid Hour team, with work from contributing researchers and students that we edit, fact-check and publish. The Paid Hour was founded by Syed Esrak Ahmmed, Founder & CEO. We are not accountants or tax advisers. Every guide is built from HMRC’s published guidance and each provider’s own documentation, with every figure linked back to its source so you can check it yourself. Anything time-sensitive carries the date it was last verified.

Spotted something wrong or out of date? Tell us, corrections get made quickly and noted on the page. More on how these guides get put together in the editorial policy.

Follow The Paid HourYouTubeLinkedInPinterest

Read next